Written By:  Holli McCray | September 2025

If your house is on the market but you haven’t gotten any offers you’re comfortable with, you may be wondering: what do I do if it doesn’t sell? And for a growing number of homeowners, that’s turning into a new dilemma: should I just rent it instead?

There’s a term for this in the industry, and it’s called an accidental landlord. Here’s how Yahoo Finance defines it:

“These ‘accidental landlords’ are homeowners who tried to sell but couldn’t fetch the price they wanted — and instead have decided to rent out their homes until conditions improve.”

 

Why This Is Happening More Often Right Now

And right now, the number of homeowners turning into accidental landlords is rising…

Basically, sales have slowed down as buyers struggle with today’s affordability challenges. And that’s leaving some homeowners with listings that sit and go stale. And if they don’t want to drop their price to try to appeal to buyers, they may rent instead.

But here’s the thing you need to remember if renting your house has crossed your mind. Becoming a landlord wasn’t your original plan, and there’s probably a reason for that. It comes with a lot more responsibility (and risk) than most people expect.

So, if you find yourself toying with that option, ask yourself these questions first:

1. Does Your House Have Potential as a Profitable Rental?

Just because you can rent it doesn’t mean you should. For example:

• Are you moving out of state? Managing maintenance remotely can be challenging.
• Does the home need repairs before it’s rental-ready? And do you have the time or the funds for that?
• Is your neighborhood one that typically attracts renters, and would your house be profitable as one?

If any of those give you pause, it’s a sign that selling might be the better move.

2. Are You Ready To Be a Landlord?

On paper, renting sounds like easy passive income. In reality, it often looks more like this:

• Midnight calls about clogged toilets or broken air conditioners
• Chasing down missed rent payments
• Damage you’ll have to fix between tenants

Landlords have to fix things like broken pipes, defunct HVAC systems, and structural damage, among other essential repairs. If you don’t have a few thousand dollars on hand to take care of these repairs, you could end up in a bind.

3. Have You Thought Through the True Costs?

According to Bankrate, here are just a few of the hidden costs that come with renting out your home:

• A higher insurance premium (landlord insurance typically costs about 25% more)
• Management fees (if you use a property manager, they typically charge around 10% of the rent)
• Maintenance and advertising to find tenants
• Gaps between tenants, where you cover the mortgage without rental income coming in

While renting can be a smart move with the proper set of parameters, if you’re only considering it because your listing didn’t get traction, let’s set up a time to discuss why it didn’t sell and determine if there is a better plan to implement that will help you meet your goals.